A process owner shows you a signed procedure. The record for the order you picked tells a different story. An internal audit should help you work out which story reflects what happened, what requirement applies and whether the same issue could affect other work. Use this checklist to follow one process from its intended controls to the evidence it leaves behind.
Disclosure: Some catalogue guides linked here offer an ANSI Webstore purchase option. European Standards may earn a commission on qualifying purchases.
ISO 19011:2026 provides guidance on auditing management systems. Use the management system standard, contract or internal procedure applicable to your audit as the source of criteria. The checklist below is a practical example you can adapt.
1. Set the audit objective before requesting records
Write one question the audit must answer. For example: “Can the dispatch team show that the required release approval preceded shipment?” Record the process boundaries, period, sites, criteria and people you need to speak to. Assign an auditor who can assess the process objectively.

2. Build a sample that can challenge your assumptions
Start with a list of orders shipped during the audit period. Pick one routine order, one expedited order and one order that changed after approval. Choose the records yourself and note why you selected them. If a sample points to a recurring issue, extend it to a second shift, date range or order type. These three orders are a worked example. Set your own sample according to the objective, risk and records available.
3. Trace a transaction through the process
For each order, compare the approved requirements, release evidence and dispatch timestamp. Ask the operator to show what happens when the normal approver is absent. If a field is blank, check whether an approved system log captured the decision elsewhere. Record where you looked, what you found and what you could not verify.
4. Write a finding another person can reproduce
Use three lines: Criterion — what did the applicable procedure require? Evidence — what record or observation supports the finding? Gap — how did the evidence differ from the criterion? For example, if release approval was required before dispatch, cite the procedure, the sampled order ID, the dispatch timestamp and the available approval record. Keep the conclusion within what those records support.

5. Check whether the corrective action worked
Ask the process owner for an action, a due date and a measure of effectiveness. If a new release control was added, sample fresh orders after implementation and check their timestamps. The audit evidence checklist shows how to build a record trail before your next audit. For a cross-functional example, see the AI impact assessment example.
Check the scope and edition of the ISO 19011:2026 auditing guide before you buy. The ISO committee’s publication record is the primary edition reference.
